How To Buy A Loose Diamond

If you're shopping for a diamond that tells your story, buying one loose — before it's set — is the best place to begin. Loose diamonds allow you to handpick the most important element of your jewelry with total transparency. You can compare, inspect, and make thoughtful decisions before your stone is ever placed in a ring, pendant, or bracelet.

Whether you're planning a proposal, upgrading a setting, or designing a completely custom piece, learning how to buy a loose diamond will help you get more value, more beauty, and more meaning from your investment. And at Garrick Jewelers in Hanover, PA, we’ll walk you through every step — from sparkle to setting.

Why Buy a Loose Diamond?

Loose diamonds give you more than just options — they give you insight. You can see the stone on its own, judge its quality clearly, and avoid distractions from pre-set designs. Here’s why that matters:

  • Full Transparency: You get to evaluate the diamond itself, not just the finished look.

  • Custom Fit: You can choose a setting that highlights the diamond’s strengths.

  • Better Value: You control the budget by prioritizing the features that matter most to you.

  • Personal Design: Start with the stone, and build the design around it — not the other way around.

What Should I Know Before Buying a Loose Diamond?

Most customers ask: “What should I look for in a diamond?” It starts with understanding the 4Cs, but it doesn’t stop there.

Understanding the 4Cs of Diamonds

The 4Cs — Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat — are the global standard for grading diamond quality. Here’s how each one plays a role in what you see (and pay for):

Cut: The Sparkle Factor

Cut refers to how well the diamond has been shaped and faceted to reflect light. It has the biggest impact on brilliance and fire — even more than carat size.

  • Excellent and Ideal cuts create the most sparkle.

  • Poor cuts can make a large diamond look dull or dark.

  • Prioritize cut if sparkle and light performance matter to you.

At Garrick Jewelers, we’ll show you side-by-side comparisons of cuts — so you can see brilliance with your own eyes.

Color: Subtle Differences, Big Impact

Color is graded from D (colorless) to Z (noticeable yellow or brown tint). The difference between each grade is subtle, but it can affect both appearance and price.

  • D–F: Colorless (premium pricing)

  • G–H: Near-colorless (great value, very popular)

  • I–J: Faint warmth, often looks white when set in yellow gold

Color is often subjective — so it’s best to view several side by side before deciding.

Clarity: What You Can (and Can’t) See

Clarity evaluates how many internal or external imperfections (called inclusions and blemishes) a diamond has.

  • FL–IF: Flawless to internally flawless (extremely rare)

  • VVS1–VS2: Very slight inclusions (eye-clean in most lighting)

  • SI1–SI2: Slight inclusions, still eye-clean in many diamonds

  • I1–I3: Visible inclusions, budget-friendly

Eye-clean diamonds (with no visible flaws) often offer the best combination of beauty and value.

Carat: Size and Weight

Carat refers to a diamond’s weight — not just how large it looks. Two diamonds of the same carat can appear different in size based on how they’re cut.

  • Popular engagement ring sizes: 0.75 – 1.5 carats

  • Fancy shapes (like oval and marquise) can look larger per carat

  • Small size differences (e.g., 0.90 ct vs. 1.00 ct) can significantly affect price

Our diamond specialists can help you find a carat weight that looks larger without exceeding your budget.

Popular Diamond Shapes (And What They Say About You)

Choosing the shape is about style, personality, and how the diamond will be worn. Here are a few of the most popular:

  • Round Brilliant: Classic, timeless, most sparkle

  • Princess: Modern, geometric, bold

  • Cushion: Romantic, soft edges, vintage feel

  • Oval: Elegant, elongates the finger

  • Emerald: Sophisticated, clean lines, step-cut

  • Pear: Unique and graceful

  • Radiant/Asscher/Marquise/Heart: All with strong personalities and distinctive appeal

Do Loose Diamonds Come with Certification?

Yes — and they absolutely should. Any loose diamond you buy should be certified by a recognized grading lab:

  • GIA (Gemological Institute of America)

  • AGS (American Gem Society)

Certification provides an independent evaluation of your diamond’s 4Cs. It ensures you're comparing apples to apples — and getting what you paid for.

Always ask to see the grading report. At Garrick Jewelers, all our loose diamonds are certified and carefully hand-selected.

Can I See a Loose Diamond in Person Before I Buy?

Absolutely — and we recommend it. Here’s what to do when viewing diamonds in-store:

  • Look under magnification to check clarity and symmetry

  • Compare color grades side-by-side

  • View under natural and LED lighting

  • Pay attention to how the diamond sparkles as you move it

  • Ask questions — we’re here to explain everything clearly

Seeing diamonds in person is the best way to understand how cut and proportions affect appearance. It’s more eye-opening than any online filter.

How Will It Look in a Ring?

Many customers ask: “How do I know what this diamond will look like once it’s set?”

At Garrick Jewelers, we can show you:

  • Sample settings with loose stones

  • 3D renderings for custom designs

  • Side-by-side views of different stone shapes and ring styles

  • Recommendations based on your lifestyle and design goals

Remember: the setting should complement the diamond, not compete with it.

Can I Design My Own Ring with a Loose Diamond?

Yes — and that’s where loose diamonds shine the brightest.

Custom Ring Design at Garrick Jewelers

  • You choose the stone. We help you bring it to life.

  • Choose from hundreds of setting styles or design your own

  • Match metals and side stones to your aesthetic

  • See renderings and wax models before final production

  • Work with our in-house experts from start to finish

  • Crafted with passion, designed to last forever.

Why Buy Loose Diamonds at Garrick Jewelers?

Here’s what makes us Hanover’s trusted destination for loose diamonds:

  • Certified diamonds from top-tier grading labs

  • Personalized one-on-one service

  • Elegant, relaxed showroom experience

  • Award-winning custom design team

  • Full after-care: resizing, appraisal, cleaning, repair

We're located at 1117 Eichelberger Street in Hanover, PA — just minutes from wherever you are.

Final Thoughts: The Diamond Comes First

Buying a loose diamond gives you the opportunity to make something personal from the start. It puts quality, choice, and creativity back in your hands — and that’s exactly where it belongs.

Whether you're creating a once-in-a-lifetime engagement ring or an heirloom piece that will be passed down for generations, the team at Garrick Jewelers is here to guide you with expertise, warmth, and care.

Discover the Perfect Diamond

Book your appointment today or visit us in-store to explore our collection of loose diamonds and custom settings.

Garrick Jewelers

1117 Eichelberger Street

Hanover, PA 17331

717-637-1177

repairs@garrickjewelers.com

www.garrickjewelers.com

Back to News